FA Trophy
| Season | Round | Team | H/A | Result | Scorers |
| 2019-20 | Prelim | Ossett Utd | H | W 3 - 2 | Fitzpatrick (2), Heslop |
| 1QR | Gainsborough Trinity | H | L 4 - 0 | ||
| 2020-21 | 2QR | Clitheroe | H | L 1 - 0 | |
| 2021-22 | 1QR | Worksop Town | H | W 3 - 2 | Capewell, Djalo, Mouanda |
| 2QR | Workington AFC | A | W 1 - 0 | Galbraith (P) | |
| 3QR | Bamber Bridge | H | W 2(p) - 2 | Djalo, Mason - (Dunston won 3-2 on pens) | |
| 1R | Marine | A | L 2 - 2(p) | Djalo, Mason - (Marine won 5-4 on pens) | |
| 2022-23 | 1QR | Mossley | A | W 2 - 1 | Fowler, Galbraith |
| 2QR | Bootle | A | W 3 - 0 | Coulson, Fowler, Thear | |
| 3QR | Ashton United | A | W 0(p) - 0 | (Dunston won 3-1 on pens) | |
| 1R | Coalville Town | H | L 3 - 1 | Jenkins | |
| 2023-24 | 1QR | Ashington | H | W 3 - 0 | Lamb, Djalo (2) |
| 2QR | Nantwich Town | A |
